Archive for the ‘Proposals for Settlement’ Category

Avert Your Eyes! Another Proposal for Settlement Fails in Florida

Monday, December 14th, 2009

The Fourth District shot down yet another Proposal for Settlement due to faulty application.  While alternative dispute methods are favored in theory, enforcing arbitration (based upon contract between the parties before suit) or Proposal of Settlement (based upon vehicle during suit) is difficult to achieve.

In Palm Beach Polo Holdings, Inc. v. Equestrian Club Estates Property Owners Association, Inc. (Kaplan, Polen, and Cikin), the court addressed a case where the complaint brought two counts for injunctive relief and one count for damages.  Can a party use a Proposal for Settlement in such situations?

Yes, but not to resolve the entire case, only the damages count.  Per Florida Statute 768.79, Proposals only apply to civil actions for damages.  In a case which is  a hybrid damages/injunction case, a general offer applying to the entire [hybrid] case is not binding.

Here, the court pointed out the strict construction analysis which plagues applies to Proposals for Settlement as well as the fact that acceptance in this case may not have ended litigation.

Joint Proposals for Settlement Continue to Fail in Florida Courts

Monday, April 13th, 2009

Recent statistics show that Florida courts, more likely than not, strike down Proposals for Settlements on appeal. So much for encouraging settlement. In fact, such was the opinion of a sitting appellate judge. In the last year, more than half of the Florida state appellate decisions involving Proposals have stricken them. Going back further, the failure rate increases.

A May 2008 First DCA opinion provided the groundwork for the theory that Proposals are tricky little creatures. More recently, in September 2008, a conflict emerged between the First and Second DCAs. On various grounds, we’ve seen the Third and Fourth Districts recently shoot down Joint Proposals in Central Hyundai v. Shaw and Brown-Eger v. Noon. A detailed article on suggested practices and wording of Proposals for Settlement can be found under “Articles” on the right column of this website (as well as here).

The issue of joint Proposals for Settlement under Florida Statute 768.79 and Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.442 jumped back to life in the March 18, 2009 Fourth District opinion of Daila Cano v. Hyundai Motor America, Inc. and Guillermo Cano, where the full court (with Hazouri concurring) held that the Proposal form was not valid.

In the Cano opinion, a dispute arose over husband and wife’s purchase of a vehicle, for which a warranty lawsuit resulted. Before trial, Hyundai served the couple with a single, joint Proposal for Settlement which did not set forth the amount of money attributed to each claimant. The case went to trial but the husband was dropped as a party. Hyundai won. The trial court upheld the Proposal nonetheless, holding it was valid because the Canos’ claims were indistinguishable.

The Fourth disagreed. Under the Brower-Eger v. Noondecision, a joint proposal shall state the amount and terms attributable to each party [Fla. R. Civ. P. 1.442(c)(3)] and our Supreme Court has rejected any deviation from the strict requirements of [F.S. 768.79] and [Rule 1.442] [which lead the court to conclude that] a settlement offer made to or from to or more parties… must specify the amount attributable to each of them.”

This, the court held, was a bright line rule. Here, there were two plaintiffs and Hyundai’s Proposal failed to specify the amount attributable to each; although their claims may have been indistinguishable, it did not change the outcome. The court found there are no exceptions to the multiple-party-appportionment-rule.

Judge Hazouri echoed the First DCA’s 2005 call for the Florida Supreme Court to re-visit Rule 1.442 in order to amend it so that it less strict and more favorable to encouraging settlements.

The Karate Kid, Part II download movie Four Rooms download movie New Rose Hotel download movie The Man download movie America's Sweethearts download movie Dracula download movie Riding Giants download movie Let's Stick Together download movie Dick Tracy download movie A Date with Judy